In the typical ZIP code in the Address District Older Home Index, older homes averaged a little under a quarter of the price of new construction. In 12 ZIP codes, the sample shows the opposite. Older homes averaged more than new ones.
| ZIP | Place | State | Homes | Older homes | Older vs new | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28704 | ArdenBuncombe County, NC | NC | 12 | 6 | 547.6% | 152 |
| 80108 | Castle RockDouglas County, CO | CO | 19 | 2 | 438.7% | 416 |
| 32967 | Vero BeachIndian River County, FL | FL | 3 | 1 | 399.3% | 707 |
| 33412 | Palm Beach GardensPalm Beach County, FL | FL | 14 | 2 | 318.1% | 420 |
| 85658 | MaranaPima County, AZ | AZ | 11 | 4 | 300.0% | 237 |
| 11746 | Dix HillsSuffolk County, NY | NY | 11 | 5 | 279.7% | 188 |
| 34211 | Lakewood RanchManatee County, FL | FL | 5 | 1 | 245.7% | 676 |
| 95746 | Granite BayPlacer County, CA | CA | 16 | 2 | 236.5% | 418 |
| 85268 | Fountain HillsMaricopa County, AZ | AZ | 14 | 7 | 160.4% | 124 |
| 85255 | North Scottsdale / DC Ranch / SilverleafScottsdale, AZ | AZ | 58 | 11 | 154.7% | 58 |
| 92026 | EscondidoSan Diego County, CA | CA | 2 | 1 | 137.2% | 762 |
| 85262 | Troon / Desert MountainScottsdale, AZ | AZ | 38 | 20 | 128.9% | 22 |
The highest figure is in Arden, North Carolina, where older homes averaged 547.6 percent of the new-build price, based on 6 older homes among 12 in the sample. Castle Rock, Colorado, is next at 438.7 percent, with 2 older homes among 19.
Small numbers, large swings
These figures rest on few homes. Across the 12 ZIP codes, 62 of the 203 homes sampled are older homes. Three of the 12 have fewer than 10 homes in the sample. When an average rests on two or three older homes, a single large estate can carry it past any new-build price.
The two Scottsdale neighborhoods in the group have larger samples. Troon and Desert Mountain rank 22nd nationally, with 20 older homes among 38, and older homes there averaged 128.9 percent of new construction. In North Scottsdale, DC Ranch and Silverleaf, 11 of the 58 homes sampled are older homes, and the figure is 154.7 percent.
The census suggests caution in Troon. Its 2020 to 2024 estimates count 169 of the 8,733 housing units in 85262 as built in 1979 or earlier, and 413 more in the 1980s, so older homes appear to be a far smaller part of the ZIP code than of the sample (U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 to 2024). Arden is a growing place. The census counts 845 housing units in 28704 built in 2020 or later and 2,757 built in the 2010s, out of 11,931, while 22.2 percent were built in 1979 or earlier (U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 to 2024). The methodology sets out how the sample and the price ratio are built.
See what a private, off-market sale of your home would look like →
Less unusual than it sounds
Nationally, existing homes have been outpricing new ones for a while. In the fourth quarter of 2025, the median new single-family home sold for $405,300 and the median existing home for $414,900, the third consecutive quarter in which existing homes cost more, the National Association of Home Builders found (NAHB, March 2026). From the second quarter of 2024, existing homes outpriced new ones in five of seven quarters, a reversal from 2010 to 2019, when new homes carried an average premium of $66,000. NAHB pointed to tight inventory, with owners who locked in low mortgage rates slow to sell, and to builders turning to smaller homes on smaller lots.
The pattern held into the summer. The median new single-family house sold in August 2026 went for $393,700 (U.S. Census Bureau, September 2026), and the median existing single-family home for $434,800 (NAR, September 2026). Those are national medians across very different houses and places. The index compares older and new homes within a ZIP code, where in most neighborhoods new construction still sells for far more, as our look at the widest gaps shows.
What it means for a sale
Where older homes outprice new ones, the sample suggests buyers are paying for the homes themselves, not only for the address. For an owner in one of these neighborhoods, that is a reason to price the home on its own merits and to compare any offer, including an off-market one, with recent sales of similar homes. Our guide to selling off-market explains how.
Sources
- Address District, The Older Home Index, October 2026
- Address District, Older Home Index methodology, October 2026
- National Association of Home Builders, Comparing new and resale prices, 4Q25, March 23, 2026
- U.S. Census Bureau, Monthly new residential sales, August 2026, Sept. 24, 2026
- National Association of Realtors, Existing-home sales report, August 2026, Sept. 10, 2026
- U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 five-year estimates, table B25034, ZCTA 85262, accessed Oct. 5, 2026
- U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024 five-year estimates, table B25034, ZCTA 28704, accessed Oct. 5, 2026


