Seller’s Desk · By Address District · · 8 min read
Should I Sell My House Off-Market? Weighing the 5 Percent Owner-Sale Share, the 23.1 Percent Price Ratio and the Single Offer
In the year to June 2025, 91 percent of U.S. sellers hired an agent, and owners who sold alone reached a median of $360,000 against $425,000 for agent-assisted sales. In the median Older Home Index neighborhood, older homes averaged 23.1 percent of new construction prices, so the yardstick for a private offer matters as much as the route.
- Off-market sales
- Older homes
- Price ratio
- Buyer identity
- Privacy
Table of contents
- Key findings
- What does a listing give an owner that a private sale gives up?
- Who buys when there is no listing?
- Why does new construction mislead an owner pricing an older house?
- Do the larger neighborhood samples tell the same story?
- How should an owner test a private offer before signing?
- What does a private sale change about exposure and privacy?
- Methodology and limitations
- Conclusion
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Sources
An owner in a house built before 1981 has watched neighbors host open houses and wonders whether there is a quieter way out. A sale without a listing keeps the rooms off the portals, but it also keeps the house from buyers who might have bid against each other, and that trade is the decision.
This brief weighs it with two bodies of evidence. The National Association of Realtors’ 2025 survey shows how few owners sell outside the agent system and who buys when they do, and the Address District Older Home Index shows how far an older house’s price can sit from new construction in the same ZIP code, before the brief weighs what a private sale changes.
Neither source measures off-market sales directly. The survey’s for-sale-by-owner group is the nearest public proxy, the index compares averages across different houses, and many of its neighborhoods rest on a handful of sampled homes. Nothing here values a particular property.
Key findings
- Ninety-one percent of sellers in the year to June 2025 used an agent, and sales by owners fell to 5 percent, an all-time low (NAR, November 2025).
- Sixty percent of owners who sold without an agent already knew the buyer (NAR, November 2025).
- Of 1,170 index neighborhoods with a price comparison, 646 had older homes averaging under a quarter of new construction prices (Older Home Index).
- Where at least 10 homes were sampled, the median ratio rose to 32.3 percent and 61 of 231 neighborhoods fell under a quarter (Older Home Index).
What does a listing give an owner that a private sale gives up?
Exposure, and the bidding it can produce. A listed house reaches every active buyer and agent in the market in the same week, and when two or more want it, the seller can let them compete. A private sale is a conversation with one buyer, whose number becomes the market for the house unless the owner looks elsewhere.
Sellers lean hard toward exposure. Ninety-one percent used an agent, matching the record, and their top priorities in choosing one were marketing the home, pricing it competitively and selling within a set time.
The survey’s price gap is the figure most often quoted and the easiest to misread. As arithmetic, the $425,000 agent-assisted median minus the $360,000 owner median is $65,000, or 15.3 percent of the higher figure. Neither median is adjusted for size, location or condition, so the gap describes two different sets of houses, not what a listing would add to any one of them.
Source NAR buyer and seller profile for 2025, released November 4, 2025, covering sales from July 2024 through June 2025.
Who buys when there is no listing?
Mostly someone the owner knows. Six in ten owners who sold without an agent knew their buyer. Arithmetic on the two survey shares puts sales by owners to people they knew at 3 percent of all sales, 60 percent of 5 percent, and their sales to strangers at 2 percent.
A direct sale to a company may be counted there or in the survey’s separate 4 percent of other sales. Some buyers in that group keep the house, and some sign a contract they mean to pass to someone else before closing. A price cannot tell them apart, so the name that will go on the deed matters as much as the number.
Source National Association of Realtors, Top 10 takeaways from the 2025 profile, November 3, 2025. Shares of all sales are arithmetic on the published percentages.
Why does new construction mislead an owner pricing an older house?
Because across most of the index the two sit far apart. For each ZIP code, the index divides the average price of its older homes by the average price of its new construction. Of the 1,170 neighborhoods with both averages, 646, or 55.2 percent, show older homes at under a quarter of new prices, and the median ratio is 23.1 percent. Only 12 show older homes averaging as much as new ones or more.
Index neighborhoods grouped by the older-to-new price ratio
The ratio compares different houses, often a postwar ranch against a large new build, so it is no discount a buyer applies. A private offer far below a builder’s asking price down the street is not necessarily low. The fair yardstick is a recent sale of a similar older house nearby, which any buyer should be able to show.
Source Address District Older Home Index, October 2026. Ratios compare average prices of different houses, unadjusted for size, lot or condition.
Do the larger neighborhood samples tell the same story?
Partly. The median neighborhood has 3 sampled homes, so many ratios rest on one or two sales. Among the 231 neighborhoods that have a ratio and 10 or more sampled homes, the median is 32.3 percent and 61, or 26.4 percent, sit under a quarter. The gap holds but softens, and older homes make up 42.0 percent of the 5,116 homes in all 238 larger samples, against 49.0 percent across the 1,192 index neighborhoods.
Table 1 lists all nine neighborhoods with at least 40 sampled homes and a majority built in 1980 or earlier. Truckee stands apart at 10.6 percent, while Belle Meade, Palma Ceia and the rest sit between about a quarter and just over a third.
| Neighborhood | Homes sampled | Older share | Older price as share of new |
|---|---|---|---|
| Truckee, California | 40 | 92.5% | 10.6% |
| Belle Meade and West Meade, Nashville | 41 | 85.4% | 27.8% |
| Palma Ceia and Sunset Park, Tampa | 53 | 77.4% | 26.3% |
| Downtown Boca and Boca Raton Riviera | 44 | 72.7% | 29.7% |
| University and Platt Park, Denver | 47 | 72.3% | 36.4% |
| Old Naples and Port Royal, Naples | 52 | 71.2% | 25.8% |
| Bluffton, South Carolina | 49 | 65.3% | 29.5% |
| Arcadia and Camelback East, Phoenix | 53 | 62.3% | 32.3% |
| Paradise Valley, Arizona | 51 | 60.8% | 34.2% |
Table 1. Every index neighborhood with at least 40 sampled homes and a majority of older homes. Source, Address District Older Home Index, 2026.
Source Address District Older Home Index, October 2026. Pooled shares and medians are calculated from the published counts.
How should an owner test a private offer before signing?
On three points, in order. First, the price against recent sales of similar older homes. Second, the terms that decide whether it arrives, the deposit and its holder, any withdrawal period, the closing date and the condition of sale. Third, the buyer. A contract that can be assigned may close with a party the owner never met, so the name that will take title belongs in writing before signing.
A lawyer’s reading is worth its fee anywhere, and some states require more, as our Connecticut closing guide explains.
Source Address District. Contract customs and closing rules differ by state.
What does a private sale change about exposure and privacy?
It swaps reach for control. Address District purchases straight from the owner. Nothing is listed, nobody tours the rooms at a showing or open house, and no fixing, staging or deep cleaning is asked of the owner. Someone from the company looks over the details and may want to visit before putting an offer on paper, and the offer commits the owner to nothing. On acceptance, the owner sets the closing for a date weeks or months away, pays no commission and learns the buyer’s identity in writing.
As arithmetic, each point of commission on the survey’s $425,000 agent-assisted median is $4,250, a figure to set beside a private offer.
What the owner gives up is competition. A listing can draw competing bids that may lift the price above any single offer. An owner who values privacy, a fixed date and an untouched house may prefer the private route anyway, and that call is the owner’s.
Source Address District terms. Commission arithmetic on the NAR agent-assisted median, with no rate assumed.
Methodology and limitations
Sales figures come from the association’s 2025 profile, covering July 2024 through June 2025. Its for-sale-by-owner group leaves out a further 4 percent of other sales, so it approximates rather than measures off-market sales.
Neighborhood figures come from the Older Home Index, which counts homes built in 1980 or earlier among sampled homes, with unknown build years counted as not older. In 644 of the 1,192 neighborhoods, 3 or fewer homes were sampled, so the larger-sample figures and Table 1 deserve more weight. Dollar figures are arithmetic, not forecasts or valuations.
Conclusion
The record supports a few plain points. Nearly every seller in the latest survey year used an agent, owner sales hit a record low and mostly went to someone known, and in most index neighborhoods older homes average well under half the price of new construction.
It does not show that a listing would bring more for a given house, or what a fair private offer is. An owner who measures an offer against similar older sales, reads the terms and gets the buyer’s name in writing can weigh competing bids against privacy and a chosen date on firm ground.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do most sellers use an agent?
Yes. In the year to June 2025, 91 percent did, and 5 percent sold on their own, the lowest share on record.
Is a private offer low if it is far below new construction prices?
Not necessarily. In the median index neighborhood, older homes average 23.1 percent of new construction prices, so compare it with recent sales of similar older homes.
Can a private sale bring as much as a listing?
It can, but nothing guarantees it. A listing can draw competing bids, while a private sale produces one offer to accept or decline.
How do I know who is buying?
Ask who will take title at closing and get the answer in writing before signing. Address District names the buyer in writing.
Sources
- National Association of Realtors, Nov. 4, 2025. NAR 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers reveals market extremes. https://www.nar.realtor/news/real-estate-news/nar-2025-profile-of-home-buyers-sellers-reveals-market-extremes
- National Association of Realtors, Nov. 3, 2025. Top 10 takeaways from NAR’s 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers. https://www.nar.realtor/news/economists-outlook/top-10-takeaways-from-nars-2025-profile-of-home-buyers-and-sellers
- Address District, October 2026. The Older Home Index. /older-home-index.html
- Address District, October 2026. How does a Connecticut closing work?. /stories/connecticut-closing-process.html
Figures retrieved October 5, 2026. This brief is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Photographs are illustrative.


